Should Christians celebrate Christmas? I know how that question sounds in November, with the lights going up and the music already playing in every store in Las Vegas. I am not asking it to be a grinch. I am asking because I care more about following Jesus than following the calendar.
Here is the honest truth: I am not convinced we should celebrate Christmas at all. I did not land here overnight, and I did not land here to judge anyone. These are the five reasons I keep coming back to.
At a Glance
1. Scripture Never Tells Us to Celebrate His Birth
Jesus gave His followers one clear instruction about remembering Him. At the Last Supper, He broke the bread and said:
“This do in remembrance of me.” Luke 22:19 (KJV)
Paul repeats it: when we eat the bread and drink the cup, “ye do shew the Lord’s death till he come” (1 Corinthians 11:26, KJV). We are told to remember His death. Nowhere in the New Testament do we see the apostles or the early church marking His birthday.
If God wanted a feast for the birth of the Messiah, He knew how to command one. He gave Israel detailed appointed times in Leviticus 23. A birthday feast for Jesus is not on that list.
2. He Was Born in the Month of Aviv, Not December
The Bible never gives a date for the birth of Jesus. It does give clues, and none of them point to winter.
“And there were in the same country shepherds abiding in the field, keeping watch over their flock by night.” Luke 2:8 (KJV)
Shepherds living outdoors with their flocks at night fits the warmer months better than the cold, rainy winter in Judea. The Biblical Archaeology Society notes that Luke’s shepherds might suggest the spring lambing season, while in December the sheep might well have been corralled. The same article points out that late-second-century Christians in Egypt recorded traditions placing His birth in the spring, around April 20 or 21.
That is why I believe Jesus was born in Aviv, the spring month God called “the beginning of months” for Israel (Exodus 12:2) and the month He brought His people out of Egypt (Exodus 13:4). The Lamb of God arriving in the season of lambs and of Passover fits the pattern of Scripture.
Bible scholars do not all agree on the season, and you should study it for yourself. But I am confident of this much: December 25 is not a date the Bible gives us.
3. The December 25 Date and Customs Have Pagan Roots
The Roman world was full of winter festivals. Saturnalia, a feast of gifts and partying for the god Saturn, ran in mid to late December. A Roman calendar from A.D. 354 lists December 25 as the birthday of Sol Invictus, the “Unconquered Sun.”
Historians still argue about whether the church picked December 25 to replace those festivals. National Geographic notes that Saturnalia ended by December 23, and that early Christian writers explaining the date did not mention it. Some scholars argue the date came from early Christian calculations, not pagan ones. I want to be fair about that.
But the customs are harder to defend. Evergreen trees, mistletoe, gift-giving feasts, and the season itself came out of winter traditions that had nothing to do with the God of Israel. God warned His people about exactly this kind of borrowing:
“Take heed to thyself that thou be not snared by following them… and that thou enquire not after their gods, saying, How did these nations serve their gods? even so will I do likewise. Thou shalt not do so unto the LORD thy God.” Deuteronomy 12:30–31 (KJV)
Good intentions do not make a borrowed tradition holy.
4. Commercialism Has Swallowed the Season
The National Retail Federation forecasts U.S. holiday retail sales in November and December 2026 will reach $1.013 trillion. That is more than a trillion dollars in two months.
I am a marketer. I know how that machine works, and I help businesses compete in it. That is exactly why I can see it clearly. For millions of families, the season means debt, stress, and pressure to buy love in a box. Then January arrives with the bills. Jesus said, “Ye cannot serve God and mammon” (Matthew 6:24, KJV). December tests that more than any other month.
5. Santa Teaches Our Kids Something Untrue
We tell children a man sees them when they are sleeping, knows when they are awake, and rewards them for being good. Then one day they find out it was never true.
What happens when those same kids hear us talk about a God they cannot see, who knows their hearts? I do not want my word about Jesus to sit on the same shelf as my word about Santa. Children need to know that what their parents tell them is true.
So What Do I Do in December?
I do not hide from my neighbors or lecture my family at dinner. I still love people, give generously, and show up. I just do not need a December holiday to do it.
Here is what I focus on instead:
- Remember His death and resurrection, the way He told us to.
- Give without a deadline. A gift in March means more because nobody expects it.
- Reach out first. The holidays are lonely for a lot of people. That is the heart of the Me 2Too Challenge.
- Study the appointed times God did give in Leviticus 23.
If Your Family Celebrates Christmas
I am not writing this to condemn you. Many sincere believers I love celebrate Christmas to honor Jesus. Romans 14 says each person should be fully persuaded in their own mind. I am sharing where I have been persuaded, and I am asking you to search the Scriptures for yourself.
If your family does celebrate, keep the focus where it belongs and spend time together. My list of the best Christmas movies for family movie night is a good place to start. Yes, Die Hard is on it.
Series: Holidays vs. God’s Calendar
Frequently Asked Questions
Does the Bible say when Jesus was born?
No. The Bible does not give a date. Clues like the shepherds in the fields at night (Luke 2:8) point many readers to a warmer season, and I believe He was born in the spring month of Aviv.
Is it a sin for Christians to celebrate Christmas?
Believers disagree. I am not convinced Christians should celebrate it, for the reasons above, but Romans 14 calls each of us to be fully persuaded in our own mind. Study it and decide before God.
Is Christmas based on a pagan holiday?
Historians debate whether December 25 was chosen to replace Roman festivals like Sol Invictus. Many Christmas customs do trace back to pre-Christian winter traditions.
What did Jesus tell us to remember?
His death. At the Last Supper He said, “This do in remembrance of me” (Luke 22:19).
Where Do You Stand?
I would rather have an honest conversation than a quiet disagreement. Do you celebrate Christmas? Have you ever questioned it? Tell me in the comments. If this made you think, share it with one person and talk it over together.
Keep reading: Christmas isn’t the only place tradition has replaced Scripture. Read The Narrow Path Has a Seventh Day: Why the Church Can’t Move God’s Sabbath.

